Auditor General Calls for Probe into MVR 59.35 Million Parking Systems Project With No Benefit

Auditor General Calls for Probe into MVR 59.35 Million Parking Systems Project With No Benefit

Politics ·
The Auditor General's Office has instructed that the issue of parking systems in the Malé region becoming unusable and causing losses to the state be investigated, and that action be taken if any party is found to have been negligent. According to the audit report of the Ministry of Housing for the years 2018-2023, 20 parking systems in Malé and Hulhumalé were contracted to STO on 26 June 2016 for MVR 59.9 million. Although MVR 59.35 million was spent from the state budget on installing the systems, no benefit was gained from them. The audit report states that although STO was contracted at that time to procure the parking systems, the agreement between STO and the Ministry of Housing was annulled on 26 June 2018, citing that the work was not proceeding adequately, and the installation of the remaining 14 parking systems was contracted to a foreign company for MVR 14.4 million. According to the audit report, although it is important to prepare a plan on how such work will be carried out and a feasibility study related to the work before commencing major projects, there is no document showing that such a study was conducted before the installation of the parking systems. While the state spent a large amount on installing the parking systems, the government changed in 2018, and as the then government did not see operating the parking systems as feasible, the audit states that a decision was made during 2022 that the parking systems installed in various areas of Malé be removed and that work on installing additional parking systems not proceed. When that work was halted, although STO handed over to the Ministry the materials brought for installing the parking systems, the audit states that it is not known what later happened to those materials. The audit has noted that although a large amount was spent on the parking system works, the public did not receive the desired benefit from this work, and that this money was spent in a manner that caused loss to the state. The audit has found that the MVR 9.8 million paid against four bills submitted by STO for Malé and Hulhumalé was not paid under the policy of paying for completed work, and that this was done according to a schedule agreed upon by both parties. According to the audit, when the agreement was annulled in 2018, only 2 parking systems had been completed up to that point. In addition, under the agreement between the Ministry of Housing and the foreign company, more than MVR 4 million was paid against two invoices submitted by the contractor. However, it is not known which area's installed parking system that invoice relates to, nor to what extent that work was completed. It is not evident from any documentation that the company had completed any parking system by the time the decision was made not to proceed with the parking system work. The audit has noted that, by the time the decision was made not to proceed with the parking system installation work due to a change in government policy, a total of MVR 13.8 million had been paid against the bills submitted in connection with this work without confirming that the work had been completed. According to the audit report, MVR 2.1 million was given to the foreign company that STO subcontracted to carry out this work, and MVR 1.4 million of that was not recovered. The audit report states that while MVR 59.35 million was spent from the state budget on the parking system project, no benefit was gained from this project, and therefore this is considered negligence of state funds. It states that this is a prohibited act as defined in the State Finance Regulation, and that the matter should be investigated through the arrangements set out in that regulation for investigating such matters, and the Audit Office has instructed that action be taken if any party is found to have been negligent.