Civil Court Denies Male City Council Stay Order Over 14 Plots Taken by Government

Civil Court Denies Male City Council Stay Order Over 14 Plots Taken by Government

Local News ·
The Civil Court has ruled that a temporary order cannot be issued to stay the implementation of the government's decision to take 14 plots of land included in the Male City Council's land allocation. The case was one the City Council had sought to have examined before filing a substantive claim with the court, in connection with a notice from the Ministry of Housing. In a letter sent by the Ministry of Housing to the City Council on the 15th of last month, the ministry stated that, by a directive from the President's Office, a decision had been made to transfer the 14 plots to state ownership. The ministry also said that any complaints regarding the plots should be submitted within 14 days. In connection with the government's decision, the Council requested an order that the plots remain as they are until the case is finally concluded. The Council stated in court that the plots generate a large monthly income and are linked to public services. It also noted that while agreements have been entered into with third parties regarding the plots, they are being taken without consultation and contrary to the Decentralisation Act, and that losing ownership would cause irreparable, major loss. The 14 plots identified by the Male City Council are: Sultan Park (an E-Sports Arena and Museum Park); Rasfannu (nothing further to be done); the area reclaimed for the fish market (a wet market); Thaisay Koshi (a temporary accommodation block for workers); Fish Market (an office and commercial building); Fishermen's Main Scale (a pump station); Local Market (a mixed-use commercial building); Kaanivaa (a recreation and commercial building); Artificial Beach (upgrading and building more facilities); Pay Toilet No. 2 (a public restroom and additional facilities); the petrol shed used by Vila Hakatha (an electric vehicle charging station); Bondibath Park (a parking building and a mixed-use commercial building); the land given to the National Library (a children's activity centre and a daycare centre); and the Male City Council's accommodation land (accommodation for labour relations). However, the state said that under the Decentralisation Act, the Cabinet is empowered to identify such locations for the implementation of the government's development projects on the Council's land. The state also said that the financial loss highlighted by the Council consists of losses that can be valued in money, and that the state is capable of providing such compensation. In addition, the state noted that this is not a situation in which a temporary order must be issued without a substantive claim. In the court's ruling, it was stated that a temporary order may be issued before a claim is filed only if there is an urgent matter under the Civil Procedure Code, or if it is absolutely necessary to establish justice. The judge stated that when the matter was filed in court many days after the letter was sent, the Council had not proven a reason for the delay in filing the substantive claim. The court also ruled that there is no situation at present that makes issuing such an order necessary to establish justice. The dispute arose between the government and the Male City Council over plots of land in Male following the opposition MDP gaining a majority in the recent local council elections. The Council has expressed concern that this is an act by the government to obstruct the Council's responsibilities, while the government says it is done out of a desire to develop those locations. When there was a need for the government to implement developmental projects, plots of land included in the councils' allocations were taken by amending the Decentralisation Act through the submission of a bill labelled the "Land Grab Bill." Under Section 2-56 of the Decentralisation Act, if a development project is to be implemented on land belonging to a council, that land may be identified by a decision of the Cabinet.