Commentary: Opposition Parties Use 'Bogeyman Fear' Against Foreign Investment for Political Gain
Opinion ·
A commentary by Ahmed Saail Ali argues that Maldivian political parties have repeatedly used fearmongering to turn the public against large foreign investments for political advantage, warning that the country's economy ultimately pays the price.
The article opens with a parable about an island where a long-time sand digger, facing competition for scarce sand, spread word of a bogeyman in the sand pits so others would stay away out of fear. The writer says this "bogeyman scare technique" is common in Maldivian politics, used especially by opposition groups to gain popularity and regain political office.
The commentary cites the 2010 concession agreement between the Maldives government, Maldives Airports Company Limited (MACL) and the GMR-MAHB consortium to lease Malé International Airport, and the attempted privatization of shares in Dhiraagu and MWSC, as instances where the then-opposition used such issues as political tools. It also points to the 12 November 2012 at-sea protest by the Dhivehi Rayyithunge Gaumee Haraka against the GMR airport deal.
The writer says the MDP, once in opposition, called for a boycott of tourism and portrayed Chinese mega projects as a "debt trap", and that it opposed a large project Saudi Arabia decided to run in F. Atoll. In turn, the PPM/PNC opposition spread baseless stories linking the MDP government to neighbouring India, including claims that Indian soldiers were present in the Maldives with weapons, and portrayed every India-assisted project as a danger, the article says.
Today, with the PNC in government, the opposition is playing the same game, the commentary argues. It says projects of world standard have been run, and that when Mohamed Ali Al'abbarr decided to invest in Rasmalé, opponents "came out having tied ribbons on their heads", linking the project to Israelis because many Maldivians are said to hate Israelis most — described as a political technique of creating fear around the name people are thought to fear most.
The writer says the lack of sincerity is shown by the shifting positions: for the government's leaders India was wrong yesterday and is equal today; for President Yameen, giving F. Atoll was acceptable, but a similar project now is wrong. It adds that for the MDP, releasing a large portion of the sea without public awareness and dividing reclaimed and unreclaimed land in the Malé area was acceptable during its government, while former Home Minister Imran Abdulla, under the guidance of former President Ibrahim Mohamed Solih, now stands in defence of the land — "It is okay for those figures to divide. It is wrong when others are to do it."
The article acknowledges that problems exist in past, present and planned projects, but argues that opposition parties stand against large foreign investments mainly to secure their own political agenda, including preventing economic success from boosting the ruling party's election prospects. It also says parties bring the rivalry of foreign powers such as India and China into domestic politics, while governments that keep large agreements secret from the people and the People's Majlis, and suddenly change laws, open the door to such suspicion.
The biggest price, the commentary says, is paid by the economy: lost investor trust, halted foreign money and revenue, lost job opportunities for youth, delayed basic services and infrastructure, and years of lost progress. It warns that playing on national sentiment creates hatred within society, isolates the Maldives internationally and damages foreign relations, with consequences for future generations.
To change this culture, the writer calls on governments to disclose complete information on major projects to the people and the People's Majlis through a transparent system, on opposition parties to stop creating "bogeyman fear" for temporary political gain and put national interest first, and on the public to learn the reality of matters rather than being caught up in political sentiment.