Court rules Mohamed Minhaj, missing at sea in 2022 launch sinking, is dead
Local News ·
The Addu Hithadhoo Magistrate Court has ruled that Mohamed Minhaj, 29, of S. Hithadhoo, Minhaa, who went missing in the sinking of a launch travelling from Malé to AA. Ukulhas on 5 October 2022, is dead.
The ruling was issued by Magistrate Rafeeuuddin Ahmed after considering a case filed by Minhaj's sister, Muzna Moosadidi, seeking a Shariah determination that he is dead. The court detailed several reasons followed under Shariah and law for determining that a missing person is dead.
According to the court, Islamic jurisprudential principles divide missing persons, or mafqud, into two main categories. The first covers situations such as travelling for trade or education and going missing without news, where death is largely not presumed. The second covers situations such as going missing from a battlefield or from a vessel that capsized — dangerous situations where death is largely presumed. The court found that Minhaj's case falls under the second category. In such situations, if no news of a missing person is received, the longest period that must be waited is four years in Hijri terms, the ruling states. Four Hijri years have now passed since Minhaj went missing (11 Rabi' al-Awwal 1448, or 23 August 2026).
The court noted that the Trans Secura launch ran aground near AA. Maalhos on the night of 5 October 2022 in rough seas, and that the time and situation were, even viewed naturally, a situation in which a person's survival is rare and the danger of drowning and perishing is extreme.
The judge placed great reliance on testimony from Ali Ahmed of Lh. Hinnavaru, the captain of the launch, who was on the vessel, drifted and reached AA. Feridhoo, and survived. Ali Ahmed said that while the two remained together at sea wearing life jackets and holding onto a fender for more than 23 hours, Minhaj's condition deteriorated greatly. He said Minhaj kept saying he was extremely weak and hungry and was experiencing difficulties. Ali Ahmed stated that at around 10:00 on the night of 6 October 2022 he lost awareness of Minhaj, and when he woke the following morning neither Minhaj nor the fender that had been in his hand could be seen. The court determined that the physical condition in which Minhaj was last seen indicated that the chances of survival were small and the likelihood of death was great.
Following the incident, the MNDF Coast Guard and the police together began efforts to search for him. Using MNDF Coast Guard ship Shaheed Ali, the Fast Interceptor Craft Hakura and a Dornier aircraft, a large area of 2,000 nautical miles was searched by sea and air. The MNDF report establishes that even this large search and rescue operation, conducted over four days for more than 96 hours, found no trace of Minhaj or his fender. Considering all these matters, the judge ruled that although he had been waited for four years in the belief that he might survive and return, since no news had been received and there was no material evidence by which he could be considered alive, there is now no Shariah and legal basis on which he can be considered alive.
At a press conference held by the police on 15 October 2022 in connection with the incident, Chief Superintendent of Police Mohamed Basheer said that after clarifying information from Ali Mohamed, the Marine Police and police in AA. Atoll together began search and rescue operations and sent a special investigation team to the atoll. Basheer noted, however, that given matters such as the location where the launch ran aground and the very large amount of oil on it, there were doubts about Ali Mohamed's statements.
The funeral prayer for a missing person is performed in absentia only when a court determines that the person is dead. In connection with the ruling of the Addu Hithadhoo Magistrate Court, the funeral prayer for Mohamed Minhaj was performed in absentia at Salman Mosque after today's Friday prayer.