Death penalty not enforced because no government dared, not because laws are lacking: MP Mauroof

Death penalty not enforced because no government dared, not because laws are lacking: MP Mauroof

Politics ·
MP for Kendhoo constituency Mauroof Zakir (Mattey) has said that the death penalty has not been enforced in the Maldives since 1954 not because of a lack of laws and regulations, but because successive governments have not dared to carry it out. Speaking during the debate on a bill outlining procedures for enforcing the death penalty by stoning, Mauroof said that in a hundred percent Islamic state there should be no further debate concerning matters established by the Holy Quran and the Sunnah of the Prophet, especially regarding qisas (retaliation). He also said that every government, when it reaches the latter part of its term, raises the matter of taking life for life for the political purpose of gaining the approval and love of the religious scholars in the country. "Even in a previous government, matters were taken to the point where it seemed a person would be killed the very next day. However, we never saw a single place where that ruling was enforced in the manner it is in the Quran, in the manner it is in the religion," Mauroof said. "So I, too, have no certainty now as to whether this is actually being done with good intent." Mauroof said that if the Islamic Shariah is to be enforced with good intent, then one must not look only at the death sentence, but must enforce all the hudud established by the Quran and the Sunnah as well, such as stoning and the amputation of the hands of thieves. "Generally, the matter of taking life for life is raised when the latter part of a term approaches. That matter is usually raised when there is a desire to gain the approval of the religious scholars in the country in various matters. As a matter to be raised to gain the love of those respected persons for a government," he said. Mauroof raised the question of whether, after courts have previously issued major verdicts to please the rulers, and those same verdicts have been changed by the very same judges, the Maldives' criminal justice system is in a state where such a ruling can be enforced justly. Under the bill concerning the enforcement of the death penalty, a seven-member panel including the Fathwa Council and the PG Office must be formed to oversee matters of enforcing the death penalty. However, Mauroof expressed concern that providing that a parliament member on that panel must withdraw from the panel if he or she says anything at all in connection with such a case is a matter that narrows the participation of members. As stated in the bill, the death penalty may be imposed on a person only after the Supreme Court, the highest judicial stage, issues a final ruling. The bill also determines that if a person has not fully received the assistance of a legal counsel from the start of the investigation until the conclusion of the Shariah proceedings, the death penalty may not be imposed on that person.