High Court Upholds Refusal to Summon President Muizzu's Testimony in 'Gaziff' Trial, Allows Eesha as Defence Witness

High Court Upholds Refusal to Summon President Muizzu's Testimony in 'Gaziff' Trial, Allows Eesha as Defence Witness

Local News ·
The High Court has upheld the Criminal Court's decision that President Mohamed Muizzu's testimony does not need to be taken as defence evidence in the trial of the 'gaziff' charge filed in connection with a documentary produced by 'Adhadhu' newspaper. However, the High Court ruled that Aishath Eesha Ashraf, who denies the gaziff charge in this case, can be accepted as defence evidence. The two officials of 'Adhadhu' newspaper, CEO Hussain Fiyaz Moosa and Editor Hassan Mohamed, had submitted President Muizzu and Eesha as defence witnesses in the trial of the gaziff charge filed against them. The trial began secretly last September. In preliminary motions filed by Fiyaz and Hassan, the Criminal Court decided not to accept the testimony of some of the persons submitted as defence witnesses, including President Muizzu, Eesha, and an expert in the criminal justice system. Fiyaz and Hassan appealed the lower court's decision to the High Court, requesting that all three persons be accepted as witnesses. During the High Court hearing, they requested that the part concerning the expert in the criminal justice system be dropped, and the High Court proceeded to decide on the matter regarding President Muizzu and Eesha's testimony. The High Court decided last Tuesday that the lower court's decision not to accept President Muizzu as defence evidence was correct, and maintained that decision. However, the High Court quashed the lower court's decision that Eesha cannot be accepted as a witness, deciding that she can be accepted as defence evidence. According to the appeal filed at the High Court, President Muizzu was submitted as defence evidence to verify the authenticity of a letter the state says was sent by President Muizzu to the police on 28 April; to tell the court through the statements in that letter that the documentary did not look into that gentleman, if it is a letter sent by the President; and because President Muizzu's letter states that 'the statements shown in Aisha's video report claiming that I committed adultery are baseless lies,' to establish that the word 'adultery' is not stated anywhere in that documentary and that the statements in the letter are not statements included in the documentary. Eesha was submitted as defence evidence because the charge of gaziff alleges that the woman speaking in the documentary is Eesha's voice, to establish that the woman's statements do not allege adultery, and to deny the matters in the charge. The lower court decided not to accept President Muizzu as defence evidence, stating that the letter submitted by President Muizzu to the police is a letter sent to investigate that case, and that it does not consider it necessary to bring that person to court to deny a matter he has denied. The lower court also stated that the statements shown in the documentary are not something that can be linked to the case in the way Eesha interprets or views them, and that whether or not adultery is alleged in the documentary would be determined by the trial. The High Court's decision stated that as no refusal regarding the authenticity of the letter is currently apparent, it does not consider that any further evidence needs to be submitted to verify the authenticity of this letter; that while President Muizzu is the complainant, the complainant is not a party that determines charges; that there is no apparent connection to an element of the charge of the prosecution in ascertaining the matter the complainant wanted investigated or in ascertaining that party's intent; that while the charge alleges that the woman speaking in the documentary is Eesha's voice, there is a possibility of considering her as evidence relevant to the charge; that there is also a possibility of considering Eesha as evidence that would help establish that a fact included in the case before the trial exists; and that in this situation, there is a possibility of considering that excluding this evidence could obstruct the building of the defence. The opinion of Judge Huzafa Mohamed, who sat on the bench of judges that heard this case at the High Court, differed regarding changing the lower court's decision not to accept Eesha as evidence and deciding that the evidence can be accepted. In Huzafa's view, the defence had not stated in the lower court any way in which Eesha's view of the statements shown in the documentary would help establish a specific element of the charge, and there is no sufficient reason that requires changing the lower court's decision. However, by the majority of the two remaining judges, Mohamed Shameez Abdulla and Abdul Maniu Hussain, the lower court's decision not to accept Eesha as evidence was quashed. The lower court's decision that President Muizzu does not need to be brought as a witness was maintained by the agreement of the three judges who heard the case at the High Court.