JSC President Husnee Mubarik Says Freedom of Expression Cannot Be Used to Attack Honour
Politics ·
The President of the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) and Member for the Manadhoo constituency, Husnee Mubarik, has said that freedom of expression is not a freedom granted without any limit or boundary, and that there should be no room to attack people's honour in the name of that freedom.
Speaking in the debate on the bill on the protection of names and honour submitted to the People's Majlis, Husnee said that while Article 27 of the Constitution grants freedom of expression, it is not a freedom granted without any limit or boundary.
'The very Article 33 of the same Constitution grants the right to protect one's name and honour. Therefore, one cannot go under the name of freedom of expression and attack a person's name and honour. That is done by trampling the freedom granted to him. Therefore, in that situation, there must be a way for the person whose honour was attacked to seek redress for what he suffered as a result. A way must be opened for that to be done within legal bounds,' Husnee said.
Regarding this bill, sponsored and submitted by Vilimale' constituency Member Mohamed Ismail, Husnee noted that this is the only regulation among those in the schedule of the law on general regulations that existed when the Constitution came into force that has so far not been changed into a law. He also said that instead of annually extending the period of the regulation on claiming compensation for defamation, the existence of such a law is also something obligatory upon the Majlis.
In addition, Husnee noted that the main reason previous laws of this type had to be abolished was that defamation had been made a criminal offence. However, he said the currently submitted bill has been designed so that if the person whose honour is attacked does not obtain a solution through out-of-court talks, compensation can be obtained through the court by filing a civil claim. He also said that this bill has been submitted under the government's legislative agenda to fill the legal vacuum.
Responding to what opposition members said in the Majlis debate, the JSC President also spoke regarding the process of removing judges. In that regard, Husnee said that judges are removed for violating the code of conduct, and that conduct matters are looked at under civil standards. He also noted that even if sent for a criminal investigation, the absence of evidence to the extent of proving a criminal charge is not a barrier to taking conduct action under civil standards, as has been determined by the higher courts of the Maldives.
Concluding his remarks, Husnee said that even after bringing the necessary amendments to the bill after consulting relevant parties at the committee stage, passing this bill is an important matter.