Judges removed for misconduct under civil standards, not criminal charges: MP Husnee
Politics ·
Manadhoo constituency Member Husnee Mubarik has said that judges are removed from their posts for violating the code of conduct, and that such cases are examined under civil standards, not on the basis of a criminal charge being established.
Speaking in the debate on the bill on the protection of name and reputation submitted to the People's Majlis, Husnee said taking action against judges is not a decision made based on the establishment of a criminal charge. He also noted that even if there is no evidence of a criminal offence against judges, there is no legal obstacle to taking disciplinary action after examination under civil standards.
Citing an example, he said that during the past MDP administration as well, several judges, including Supreme Court judges, had been removed from their posts after certain disciplinary matters were noted and seen by the Judicial Service Commission (JSC). He noted that no criminal investigation had been completed against any of those judges, and no verdict had been issued.
"Judges were removed during the MDP administration as well. Criminal accusations were made, and they were sent for criminal investigation. Supreme Court judges were also removed. Even after criminal investigations were conducted on those judges and submitted, but against which judge was a criminal investigation concluded and a charge filed?" Husnee asked.
Highlighting the importance of protecting reputation, Husnee said that although Article 27 of the Constitution guarantees the freedom of expression, it is not a freedom without any limits. He also reminded that Article 33 of the Constitution grants every citizen the fundamental right to the protection of name and reputation.
"Using another person's reputation as a shield while under the shelter of the freedom of expression is not something acceptable. That is using a granted right in the wrong way. In such situations, there must be a strong legal framework through which parties harmed can obtain justice and their rights," Husnee said.
Furthermore, noting that the main reason a law previously passed to stop defamation later had to be repealed was because it was defined as a criminal offence, he said that the bill now submitted is designed so that redress can be sought by filing a civil claim for defamation. He also said that under the government's legislative agenda, this bill was submitted to address the legal vacuum that currently exists.
Concluding his remarks, the Member said that even if the bill does not pass in its current form, it is very important for the benefit of the whole community that consultations be held broadly with relevant parties at the committee stage and that this bill be passed quickly with the necessary amendments.