Majlis divided over interpretation of Israeli entry ban in Immigration Bill
Politics ·
A heated debate erupted in the People's Majlis on Wednesday after PNC and MDP members offered conflicting interpretations of a provision in the Immigration Bill that bars Israelis from entering the Maldives.
The bill, submitted by the government through Kulhudhuffushi North constituency member Mohamed Dawood to re-draft the Immigration Act, was debated in today's sitting.
Galolhu South constituency member Meekail Ahmed Nasim said the bill does not bar dual-passport holders who are Israelis from entering the Maldives. He said many members of the Israeli military hold dual passports, and therefore even if entry on an Israeli passport is barred, those people would still be able to come.
"Even today, during this debate we are holding, Israeli citizens are entering this country, the honourable President, this is a fact. Many of Israel's citizens are people who hold dual passports. 80 percent of Israel's Israeli Defence Force are dual passport holders," Meekail said.
He further suspected that the Immigration Bill this time too contains the matter of barring Israelis from entering the Maldives "in the manner of doing so under a name."
Vaikaradhoo constituency member Hussain Ziyad also said that the bill does not bar dual-passport holders who are Israelis from entering the Maldives.
Responding to Meekail's suspicion, Maafannu West constituency member Mohamed Musthafa Ibrahim said the bill clearly bars any person who holds an Israeli passport from entering the Maldives even on another passport, referring to Article 46 of the bill. That article states that while there is a list of persons who will not be granted permission to enter the Maldives, item (m) of that list reads "parties who hold Israeli passports."
"What are the parties who hold Israeli passports? Look, it was from this Majlis of ours that the government sent and banned the Israeli passport. The meaning of that is that the opportunity to come on a second passport other than that passport still exists. Some of them hold dual passports. Therefore they can still come to Maldives on the second passport, that is happening, I too accept. We cannot stop that either, because at that time what we banned was the Israeli passport," he said.
However, he said that with the amendment now brought, that will no longer be the case.
"What we are now barring through this law is that no party who holds an Israeli passport can enter this Maldives, the meaning of that is that even holding a second passport or holding a third passport, one cannot enter this place," Musthafa said.
He said that although what was barred previously was the passport, this time what is being barred is the person who holds the passport, and that this is very clearly evident.
Before him, Baarah constituency member Ibrahim Shujau also said that after the Immigration Bill becomes law, Israelis will have no opportunity at all to enter the Maldives.
Separately, the Real Estate Bill has been amended to prevent those barred from entering the Maldives from buying property in Rasmalé. With this change, no person holding an Israeli passport will be able to buy property in Rasmalé. A person against whom the International Criminal Court has issued an arrest order, and a person against whom a case claim is received, also will not be able to buy property.
According to what is stated in the Real Estate Bill now submitted, the opportunity to buy property and invest from an integrated real estate zone will not be available to any person barred under Maldives' immigration law. Therefore, such parties will not be able to be part of the project being run in Rasmalé by UAE's Eagle Hills.