Majlis Judiciary Committee Summons JSC Over Lack of Appeal Deadlines for Prisoners

Majlis Judiciary Committee Summons JSC Over Lack of Appeal Deadlines for Prisoners

Politics ·
The People's Majlis Judiciary Committee has passed a decision to summon the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) to address the absence of a specific legal time limit for concluding appeal cases filed by persons serving prison sentences, warning that this gap is causing fundamental rights violations. The decision was made in a committee meeting held in connection with a matter submitted by Member for Galolhu North Constituency Mohamed Ibrahim (Kudoo). Speaking in the committee's debate, Member for Kendhoo Constituency Maumoon Zakir (Mattay) said the issue is of great importance and must be resolved within the committee's mandate. He noted that when a verdict has been issued and the appeal stage concludes after the prison sentence has already been fully served—especially in situations where the offense is not proven—it amounts to a very major violation of a right. Maumoon said that in a situation where a verdict is issued irregularly, a person spends one year in prison, and a higher court later rules that he is innocent, that is not something that can be permitted even by way of compensation. Detailing the legal framework, Member for Hulhudhoo Constituency Mohamed Shahid said Article 50 of the Constitution of the Republic of Maldives guarantees the right of appeal to every person, while Article 42(a) and Article 51(b) guarantee the right to have the matter adjudicated and concluded within a reasonable period. Shahid said that although the Criminal Procedure Law sets the periods within which an appeal must be made, the absence in any law of a specific period within which the appeal case of a person serving a sentence must be concluded is a major problem in the justice system. The Judiciary Committee has decided that, after consulting with the JSC, if a change to the law is needed, it should be sent to the Attorney General's Office. The matter came to public and members' attention in connection with the case in which the High Court ruled that the offense was not proven against Mohamed Sulaimhaan, a Sri Lankan national who was serving a one-year prison sentence after being accused of smuggling two kilos of gold hidden on his body into the Maldives. The High Court quashed the Criminal Court's verdict and freed him on the day the one-year prison sentence had been fully served.